Too Old to Die Young
- Persona
- Joined: Wed Mar 07, 2018 1:16 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I don't know, right now it reminds me the most of Only God Forgives (which, like you, I didn't like) but I haven't gotten too far into it yet. Its greater variety of characters and narrative threads will probably prove a boon but then on the flip-side it is much longer than Only God Forgives so...
I do appreciate Refn's aesthetic having this much room to breathe because it does lead to some pretty immersive moments that kind of just stretch out all around you and you're just there with these characters--but then other aspects of the writing and characterizations kind of actively work against that immersion. It's very Refn but the indulgence of this being 13 hours with a plot that seems like it would have been 3 hours for most shows definitely imbues it with a singular sort of vibe (and I think that's where some of the Twin Peaks: The Return comparisons come in, even as ultimately different as Refn and Lynch are).
I do appreciate Refn's aesthetic having this much room to breathe because it does lead to some pretty immersive moments that kind of just stretch out all around you and you're just there with these characters--but then other aspects of the writing and characterizations kind of actively work against that immersion. It's very Refn but the indulgence of this being 13 hours with a plot that seems like it would have been 3 hours for most shows definitely imbues it with a singular sort of vibe (and I think that's where some of the Twin Peaks: The Return comparisons come in, even as ultimately different as Refn and Lynch are).
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I felt pretty much the same across the board on those three Refns, though I liked the end of Neon Demon more the second time. While I also consider this to be his “magnum opus,” like others, for me this started off feeling too slow and indulgent, but once it started grooving none of these stylistic methods felt like handicaps and instead created a trance-like state where I was able to access all offerings in ways I hadn’t before- which makes me wonder whether all of his work would have benefited from this long format to let the style settle. I do believe that it helps that by this point one knows what to expect with Refn, and can’t help but wonder if Neon Demon came out before Only God Forgives after the liberally-balanced style and pace of Drive, would more people still like former rather than the latter? Part of me wonders if, despite Refn having established his preferred style pre-Drive, a lot of hate (mine included) to Only God Forgives is a product of timing, and I look forward to a rewatch soon post-TOTDY to re-evaluate my thoughts.
This is a strong reading that hits on many of the larger macro-systemic reasons for this film’s intelligence in that Refn uses these 13 hours to paint a clear vision of the world (America included) and meditate on life itself as an extra dimension trying to coexist with that world, exploiting both tangible structures and systems (i.e. police, societies, culture) and philosophical ideas (loyalty, morality). The demonstration of police as absurd also fits with Martin’s breakout from the state of apathy in his socially-constructed occupation with acute elation when he gets the opportunity to kill for Jena’s cult, committing a self-perceived authentic and purposeful act to momentarily escape that paradigm of artificial ‘order,’ ironically by forfeiting to violence and subscribing to the culturally-conditioned perspective of this act as the only expression of personal justice, thus bound to the normative consumption pattern of values - or lack thereof, when falsely believing himself to be freely executing his will for the first time (though there’s always the further reading that all value is subjectivity and so regardless of the objective facade of authenticity, if Martin gets his only emotional fix from this subjective sense of purpose, perhaps that’s as authentic as one can get; a perspective Refn doesn’t indicate sharing but keeps himself maturely reserved enough to leave on the table).John Cope wrote: ↑Thu Jun 20, 2019 4:02 amIt's also one of the very finest portraits of America (by anyone) that I can think of, even as it has broader social and even cosmological implications; it is rich and horrifically resonant as a mirror back to us of our own abiding obsessions, even poisonous cultural lineage, of violence as a virtually inescapable paradigm for both action and perception. In that regard the monologue at the end by Jena Malone (always sooo great) is kin to the TLJ speech at the end of No Country for Old Men. And the indictment is to all for sinking into a mass of power hungry rage (even as it may be justified, substantiated, argued away), a conflagration finally of epic proportions. That's also why we get the police department scenes. At first I simply took these as welcome comic relief but they become so clearly and progressively isolated that their absurdity becomes paramount. The idea of "police" becomes either an obscenity or an absurdity.
The obsession with characters drawn to exaggerated stylistic fantasy narratives born from media is something Refn has been playing with this complexly at least since Drive, but here he has the time to generously explore these ideas. I also agree that this went to interesting new places unexpectedly, even for Refn who as an already unpredictable director with some predictable routes forfeits many of these. This flexibility in perspective only helped to flesh out a meditation on greater systemic forces that are always present in his work, but never before have they felt like they had enough time to explore adequately beyond the people struggling within them.
I like this take a lot and it helps to explain and expand on what I was trying to grasp at in my initial interpretation. However, I can’t think of many other scenes in the film that match it on a level nearly as esoteric.. I’m curious are there other examples of these “heightened expressionistic manifestations” that defy our logic yet belong to the logic of this universe in the same way as this scene plays?John Cope wrote: ↑Thu Jun 20, 2019 4:02 amAs to the question above about episode 7:
.SpoilerShowI didn't take the scene literally but rather as another heightened expressionistic manifestation, this time one that serves to indicate the range and extent of the Baldwin character's reach, his power; that it is, like so many other powerful figures, almost but significantly not quite godlike.
Last edited by therewillbeblus on Fri Jun 21, 2019 12:24 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Joined: Wed Mar 16, 2005 9:20 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
How is Brubaker's contribution? He's really been one of the key writers of modern film noir.
His work is so plot and character driven that I'm perplexed at how well he'd work out with Refn directing his scripts. I love the high concept of Westworld but the HBO series has been a mixed bag. The episode Brubaker wrote was probably the best of that series.
His work is so plot and character driven that I'm perplexed at how well he'd work out with Refn directing his scripts. I love the high concept of Westworld but the HBO series has been a mixed bag. The episode Brubaker wrote was probably the best of that series.
- Feiereisel
- Joined: Fri Aug 16, 2013 9:41 am
Re: Too Old to Die Young
Brubaker is credited with Refn as the co-creator and co-writer for I believe all but one of the episodes of the series. He also has a producer credit. Even so, the unique tone, pace, and aesthetic of the show makes it feel more like Refn's baby.ianungstad wrote: ↑Fri Jun 21, 2019 12:23 amHow is Brubaker's contribution? He's really been one of the key writers of modern film noir.
His work is so plot and character driven that I'm perplexed at how well he'd work out with Refn directing his scripts. I love the high concept of Westworld but the HBO series has been a mixed bag. The episode Brubaker wrote was probably the best of that series.
That said, longtime readers of Brubaker's creator owned comics work--especially Criminal, Fatale, and Kill or be Killed--will find recognizable elements of his work in the show. His presence is largely felt in the conceits/archetypal aspects of the characters and the looming sense of noir-ish "inevitability" that suffuses the narrative, but there are also some aesthetic pieces that feel like they originate with Brubaker. In a couple cases--Yaritza and Diana--it's almost as if his frequent comics collaborator Sean Phillips' art has walked right off the page and into frame.
Brubaker wrote about the show in the back pages of the most recent issue of Criminal, saying:
TOO OLD TO DIE YOUNG - As I've mentioned several dozen times, I'm sure, this is the TV show I co-created with Nicolas Winding Refn. It's out on June 14th on Amazon Prime Video, and if you're a fan of what I do, but especially if you're a fan of what Nicolas Refn does, you're going to want to check this show out. It is unlike anything out there, by a wide margin, so expect weird and shocking and hypnotic and gorgeous, all at the same time. Do not expect anything resembling a traditional TV series. Refn directed every episode, and I have been describing it to friends as a series of interlinked movies, that get more surreal as they go along. This is a one-time event, and I doubt even in this crazy era of streaming, that we'll ever see anything quite like it again.
- lzx
- Joined: Sat Jul 19, 2014 7:27 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
Cancelled, in order for Amazon to focus on "blockbuster content"
-
- Joined: Tue Dec 26, 2017 5:35 am
Re: Too Old to Die Young
Good. I mean I overall enjoyed it but it really did feel like a one and done sorta thing.
- dda1996a
- Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2015 6:14 am
Re: Too Old to Die Young
Did this have any plans for more seasons? Haven't seen it yet, but I though it was a limited series (not that that stopped anyone before)
-
- Joined: Sun Jul 19, 2009 12:45 am
Re: Too Old to Die Young
Looks like none of their more popular series have gotten a physical release... but the first season of Alpha House did!flyonthewall2983 wrote: ↑Fri Jun 14, 2019 9:08 amThere are Netflix shows which get physical releases, mostly shows which are not produced entirely by them. Amazon's movies get physical releases, but not sure if a series of theirs ever did.
-
- Joined: Mon Jun 27, 2005 3:31 pm
- Location: Indiana
- Contact:
Re: Too Old to Die Young
This is just me but I really just prefer to either have shows digitally or not buy them at all and wait until they come on any of their platforms. I do make exceptions, but as it is I have not really watched my Breaking Bad Blu-ray set much.
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
My thoughts exactly. This is one of the best films I’ve seen this year so far, and I say that (obviously) in interpreting it as one long film. It works much better that way and had a pretty perfect ending, but dragging it on any longer probably would have been a mistake. I do wonder if Refn has any plans for a second season or these characters and what he would have done with them, but if he feels passionately enough maybe we’ll see that vision in a different form.black&huge wrote: ↑Sun Jul 28, 2019 4:45 amGood. I mean I overall enjoyed it but it really did feel like a one and done sorta thing.
- tenia
- Ask Me About My Bassoon
- Joined: Wed Apr 29, 2009 11:13 am
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I'll probably never get accustomed to series being called films (yes, even the new Twin Peaks season).
- knives
- Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2008 6:49 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I absolutely loved this. Probably the closest thing we'll get to Jodorowsky's Dune. The degree to which NWF is a slave to his mentor on this is impressive so that by the final two episodes we get a pseudo re-imagining of Santa Sangre. Though for me the most impressive moment is in episode 5 with the chase sequence and its bizarre use of the sound of the electric car. I wish this rather than True Detective is what people are interested in.
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
As I wrote more in depth about a year ago on its release, I think it's his crowning achievement and probably the closest he's come to expressing his vision of the world through art.
- knives
- Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2008 6:49 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I still think Only God Forgives as his apex, but this is definitely an essential transition into something totally cosmic. It's kind of an encyclopedia of indigenous mysticism, incest, sex and violence, primitivism, love, race, and all of the other nonsense that sums up my undergrad years. It's a wonderful summary of Jodorowsky, Pasolini, and Deleuze. What's best though is for all of this high falunting language is that it's such a hilarious film (I think that's the real Lynch connection). The conversations between Jesus' underlings are great for example and shows our world is in the real world of the film. Hell, even Teller's workplace stuff is saved due to the Michael Schur parody.
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I think that gets at Refn's allure, mainly that he sees the world as a brutal, violent place but also one that is absurdly hilarious, yet he has the utmost respect for it which transcends typical absurdism into a new definition entirely (not in the least as a joke). He sees these poles, that would frighten or repel many people, as inherently beautiful - and takes life incredibly seriously in his own unique rhythm that isn't overcooked on either side, despite a style that is gushing. This film was the first to really make me understand that this intense methodology was intended to paint his personalized gorgeous worldview, on his terms but ones that were accessible and actually aligned with my own, rather than to artificially exaggerate one of those poles. I say that as someone who was very emotionally moved by Drive, but this film fleshes out a deeper, complex portrait of his fundamental cosmic perspective that reflects a (perhaps twisted) form of realism.
- knives
- Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2008 6:49 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I don't think there's a bit there. I was thinking throughout that a difference between him and a Tarantino is that Refn isn't a moralist and unapologetically gets glee from violence. In a normal morality Malone would unapologetically be the good pole, but there's such a love for Yaritza and Jesus that those poles are rendered equivalent from a moral standing.
That also goes to my larger view of Refn as a filmmaker largely working in an empathetic mode wherein the films become their leads. In his whole career only the brothers in ep. 5 strike me as being unloved and even then there's this emotional reality we are presented with in the end. It doesn't hurt to have James Urbaniak who I literally shouted with glee at seeing before thinking oh no.
That also goes to my larger view of Refn as a filmmaker largely working in an empathetic mode wherein the films become their leads. In his whole career only the brothers in ep. 5 strike me as being unloved and even then there's this emotional reality we are presented with in the end. It doesn't hurt to have James Urbaniak who I literally shouted with glee at seeing before thinking oh no.
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I'm confused, you "don't think there's a bit" of what?
I agree re: Refn's take on morality and empathy, which I went into more depth with in my longer writeups in this thread, and is what I'm talking about when I say it's a combination of poles in his version of realism and accentuated emotionality - and how it mimics my own fusion of polarized viewpoints into one, of moral relativism and empathy through acknowledging beauty, in all its definitions.
I agree re: Refn's take on morality and empathy, which I went into more depth with in my longer writeups in this thread, and is what I'm talking about when I say it's a combination of poles in his version of realism and accentuated emotionality - and how it mimics my own fusion of polarized viewpoints into one, of moral relativism and empathy through acknowledging beauty, in all its definitions.
- knives
- Joined: Sat Sep 06, 2008 6:49 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
The beauty of autocorrect. That was supposed to be 'but' in reference to you usage of that word.
- therewillbeblus
- Joined: Tue Dec 22, 2015 3:40 pm
Re: Too Old to Die Young
I used it twice, I assume you mean the first one. Agreed, "but" is the wrong word, though I see that and "and" as synonymous therapeutically as reframes - the latter of which is always preferred so I'm off my own game. I think we see eye to eye here- and my sentences following that initial sentence should have clarified that semantics splitting for itself, as I attempted to explain how in his world there is room for both. I do think I explained this all better with it fresh in my mind across the last few pages of the thread a year ago though.